Frotz

@frotz@grenzland.club

RPG account for a boring old man
homepage: https://grenzland.club/~frotz/
general-purpose Mastodon: https://mastodon.sdf.org/@frotz
English, Deutsch, 简体中文, 日本語
Blog: https://grenzland.club/~frotz
2 ★ 0 ↺

Frotz »
@frotz@grenzland.club

@randomwizard@vivaldi.net
I personally hate the idea of "level-appropriate" encounters, or the way some modern systems set up encounters like a computer rpg with "solvable" combats.

I could froth at the mouth over it, because even with modern RPGs I don't run games this way, but there is an expectation from many players that this is the structure of the game.

😡
@kensanata@tabletop.social

    ...

    Baroness Winter »
    @BaronessWinter@beige.party

    @frotz @randomwizard @kensanata

    D&D has had "encounter balancing" since as far back as BECMI / RC. It was never there to level-lock your encounters. It was there to let you estimate how difficult a given encounter would be. This whole rage against it really makes me roll my eyes. As far as WoW goes, that's an MMO, and just one of many (City of Heroes doesn't do this, for example). Not a tabletop RPG.

      ...
      0 ★ 0 ↺

      Frotz »
      @frotz@grenzland.club

      @BaronessWinter@beige.party I think there's a difference between having a method or system to give one an idea of how difficult an encounter might be, versus structuring gameplay so that encounters are never more than _X_ levels above the expected average party level.
      You're right this has been around a long time, though I have never been fond of e.g., roughly 13 encounters per level of advancement, with 50% at APL, as one school of adventure design would have it. A treadmill is a treadmill, whether it's level 2 or 20.

      @randomwizard@vivaldi.net @kensanata@tabletop.social

        ...
        1 ★ 0 ↺

        Frotz »
        @frotz@grenzland.club

        ...

        Baroness Winter »
        @BaronessWinter@beige.party

        @frotz @randomwizard @kensanata You can still keep a Mighty Beast around that will absolutely slaughter foolish adventurers and Is To Be Avoided At All Costs. Or an entire horde of lower-level enemies that will swarm the same. Anybody telling you that you can't/should never do that is, well, dead wrong. In this, I believe we agree.

          History