Frotz
@frotz@grenzland.club
@frotz @phf @twwombat I think you have the right of it. "Strength bows" seem to have been one of those things "everybody knows", like certain houserules in Monopoly. And I definitely recall being disappointed that 3e/3.5 didn't add DEX bonus to at least mechanical (box/xbow) ranged damage. I believe that came in with 4e and persisted into 5e/5.5.
@BaronessWinter AD&D DMG page 64 under "Strength Bonus Considerations" so it's Gygax vintage. @frotz @twwombat
BTW the paragraph on dexterity right after the strength thing is one of those things ... that nobody I know and played AD&D with remembers either: the DEX modifier is applied to initiative so you can lose initiative but thanks to DEX still fire first anyway 😬 AD&D certainly is a glorious mess! @BaronessWinter @frotz @twwombat Also paging AD&D referee in chief @kensanata here! 😁
Jeebus H. Cringles what a page in the DMG!! The NEXT paragraph tells us that DEX doesn't adjust armor class against giants throwing boulders at the poor party. What? @BaronessWinter @frotz @twwombat @kensanata